Author Archive

Simon Greenwood
I am one of the Directors at Camp Shane.
---

Why We Get Fat

Monday, January 3rd, 2011

In a society where weight loss follows the latest trends, a new view point has emerged from science journalist, Gary Taubes, who has a different opinion in his book, Why We Get Fat and What to Do About It. His ideas are highlighted in a recent New York Times article, written by Abigail Zuger, M.D.

Mr. Taubes argues that we’ve got this whole weight loss thing backwards.  He says the overweight are not lazy people who eat too much and exercise too little.  The thin are not virtuous and disciplined.

Rather, all of us are fulfilling a fixed biological mandate, just as growing children are.  In simple terms, our bodies have an agenda and are sticking to it- it is our behavior that evolves to make that agenda happen, Tabues says.  In this case, our bodies would be winning the war against our mind.  Therefore, if you are motivating yourself to get off the couch and go to the gym, that’s the sign of a body programmed to remain lean.

“Those who get fat do so because of the way their fat happens to be regulated,” Mr. Taubes writes.  “A conspicuous consequence of this regulation is to cause the eating behavior (gluttony) and the physical inactivity (sloth) that we so readily assume are the actual causes.”

Mr. Taubes believes that the actual causes are the array of regulatory enzymes and hormones that move fuel, in the form of fat and sugar molecules, in and out of the storage depots around the body.  Mr. Taubes goes so far as to argue that if a body is programmed to be fat, even a piece of fruit will make you that much fatter.  (This could be bad news for those following the new Weight Watchers “Points Plus” program, which puts all fruit at 0 points.)

There may never be a clear answer when it comes to the “right” diet or weight loss plan, though we do find Mr. Taubes theories inherently questionable.  Taken to the extreme, his philosophy could be relied upon by those struggling with an unhealthy weight and poor eating habits to “give up” and say they can’t change those habits because they are pre-destined!  We agree that every person is different in terms of what works best for them.  At Shane Weight Loss Camps & Resorts, the most important lesson is that of a healthy lifestyle.  Regardless of each person being different, eating healthy and exercising is always a positive experience, in our opinion.  Plus, it does get results!

What are your thoughts on Mr. Taubes’ unique view point?  Do you agree that each body is set to an agenda and you’re programmed to accommodate it?  We’d love to hear your thoughts on this very interesting topic.

Share
Google Buzz
Email This Post Email This Post

Controlling Emotional Eating During the Holidays

Tuesday, February 9th, 2010

Happy Valentine’s Day!

This holiday is a time when we can show others how much we care about them. While our friends and families play an important role in our eating habits and patterns, so do our emotions. Emotional eating occurs when we eat for reasons other than physical hunger, such as loneliness, depression, or boredom, to take our minds off of these emotions. Below are tips on to how to control this pattern:

• Keep a food journal. Seeing your calorie intake on paper puts into perspective how much we are consuming. Write down your mood when you eat to determine patterns of emotional eating.

• Before you plop down in front of the TV with a box of your favorite treats, pause for a moment and think about how you are feeling. Anxious, hopeless, upset? Keep in mind that you cannot eat through these emotions and instead find other ways to channel your feelings. Make a list of some activities you enjoy such as reading, writing, walking the dog, or playing a game. Next time you feel a craving coming on, take out your list and engage in one of those activities instead of eating.

• Meal times are typically enjoyed with friends and family. Share your nutrition goals with your loved ones so they can help you on this journey; chances are they want the same thing! Get everyone involved when planning meals so that you can all be accountable for each other.

Share
Google Buzz
Email This Post Email This Post

Overweight Children: Tips for the Holidays

Friday, November 27th, 2009

December - It’s Party Time! With the Holiday Season still in full swing it may be easy to lose sight of your health goals. It’s hard if you are a kid trying to lose weight. Hear are some ways to stay on track:

Plan ahead

  • Eat a healthy meal before the party to curb your intake of empty calorie foods.
  • Do a little extra physical activity on the day of the party.
  • Plan to bring a healthy dish you can eat and would like to share with others.

During the party

  • Drink water; thirst may sometimes be mistaken as hunger which may lead to overeating
  • Sit down while eating to help minimize mindless snacking.
  • Avoid socializing near the food table.
  • Be mindful of drinks other than water; most party drinks, including alcohol, are empty calories.
  • Watch your portions. No food is forbidden but smaller portion make a huge difference.

Post Party

  • Get back into normal eating habits and don’t skip meals to compensate for excess calories.
  • Don’t beat yourself up if you make unhealthy choices. Everyday is a new chance to start fresh and make better choices.
Share
Google Buzz
Email This Post Email This Post

Let’s “Chew” The Fat

Monday, December 8th, 2008

We all need fats. (Sounds weird, I know, but hear me out.) Fats help nutrient absorption, nerve transmission and maintain cell membrane integrity. However, when consumed in excess amount, fats contribute to weight gain, heart disease and childhood obesity.

The effects of eating habits on childhood obesity are difficult to determine. A three year randomized controlled study of 1,704 3rd grade children which provided two healthy meals a day in combination with an exercise program and dietary counseling failed to show a significant reduction in percentage body fat when compared to a control group. This occurred even though dietary fat intake decreased from 34% to 27%. A second study of 5,106 children showed similar results. (The CATCH Cohort)

Why these studies did not bring about the desired effect of curbing childhood obesity has been attributed to the interventions not being sufficient enough. Changes were made primarily in the school environment while it is felt that they must occur in the home, the community, and the school simultaneously to have a significant effect.

Contrary to popular belief, fats are not created equal. Some fats promote our health positively while others increase our risks of heart disease and obesity, including childhood obesity. The key is to replace bad fats with good fats in our diet.

Healthy Fats

  • Monounsaturated fat remains liquid at room temperature but may start to solidify in the refrigerator. Foods high in monounsaturated fat include olive, peanut and canola oils. Avocados and most nuts also have high amounts of monounsaturated fat.
  • Polyunsaturated fat is usually liquid at room temperature and in the refrigerator. Foods high in polyunsaturated fats include vegetable oils, such as safflower, corn, sunflower, soy and cottonseed oils.
  • Omega-3 fatty acids are polyunsaturated fats found mostly in seafood. Good sources of omega-3s include fatty, cold-water fish, such as salmon, mackerel and herring. Flaxseeds, flax oil and walnuts also contain omega-3 fatty acids, and small amounts are found in soybean and canola oils.

Harmful Fats

  • Saturated fat is usually solid or waxy at room temperature, saturated fat is most often found in animal products — such as red meat, poultry, butter and whole milk. Other foods high in saturated fat include coconut, palm and other tropical oils.
  • Trans fat is also referred to as trans-fatty acids. Trans fat comes from adding hydrogen to vegetable oil through a process called hydrogenation. This makes the fat more solid and less likely to spoil. Hydrogenated fat is a common ingredient in commercial baked goods — such as crackers, cookies and cakes — and in fried foods, such as doughnuts and french fries. Shortenings and some margarine also are high in trans fat. Food manufacturers are required to list trans fat content on nutrition labels. Amounts less than 0.5 grams per serving are listed as 0 grams trans fat on the food label.
  • Dietary cholesterol comes from animal products, such as meat, poultry, seafood, eggs, dairy products, lard and butter. Your body naturally manufactures all of the cholesterol it needs.

Tips for Choosing the Best Types of Fat

  • Sauté with olive oil instead of butter.
  • Use olive oil instead of vegetable oil in salad dressings and marinades. Use canola oil when baking.
  • Sprinkle slivered nuts or sunflower seeds on salads instead of bacon bits.
  • Snack on a small handful of nuts rather than potato chips or processed crackers. Or try peanut butter or other nut-butter spreads — non-hydrogenated — on celery, bananas, or rice or popcorn cakes.
  • Add slices of avocado, rather than cheese, to your sandwich.
  • Prepare fish such as salmon and mackerel, which contain monounsaturated and omega-3 fats, instead of meat one or two times a week.
Share
Google Buzz
Email This Post Email This Post

Just Say “NO!” to Childhood Obesity

Wednesday, December 3rd, 2008

“No.” Kids hate to hear it, and you hate to say it — but how else can you keep them safe and well behaved?

Childhood obesity is an increasing problem. In addition to educational efforts to get parents to teach their children to eat well and exercise more, kids are turning to adult obesity treatments, including weight loss drugs and surgeries.

Overweight children are more than likely to be overweight adults. Successfully treating and taking active steps to prevent childhood obesity may reduce the risk of having our children grow up to be laden with heart disease, diabetes and other related co-morbidities.

Dr. Phil explained why it’s important to put your responsibility as a parent above your desire to give your overweight children what they want on his show, (February 2003 “My Big Fat Baby”).

  • If you are worried about hurting your child’s feelings by not giving him/her what he/she wants to eat, remember that refusing to give your child unhealthy foods could actually save his/her life.
  • Understand that it’s not always important that your child likes you. Sometimes what is important is that your child respects the boundaries that you’ve put down. It’s your job to do what you need to do as a parent to ensure your child’s well being, including doing everything possible to prevent childhood obesity, whether he/she likes it or not.
  • The fact that you may be uncomfortable saying no to your child does not release you of your responsibility to do so when it’s in your child’s best interest. That’s why parenting is hard. Parents have to step up to the plate and do what needs to be done, whether they end up being the bad guy or not.
  • Remember that your job as a parent is not to tell your child what he/she wants to hear but what he/she needs to hear. Overweight children are neither happy nor healthy children
  • Do not use food as a reward. You can love your child in different ways without food. Why not reward your child with your time? Reading a bedtime story, taking a walk or playing catch are things you can do to connect with your child and make them feel special without unnecessary calories.
  • Don’t use food to medicate your child emotionally. It might make your child feel good for the moment, but he/she could pay a high physical, emotional and social price for your unwillingness to step up and do what is required instead of what feels good at the time.

Childhood obesity is very difficult to treat, since it involves permanently changing basic eating and exercise habits. Successes almost always involve changing the whole family’s habits to ones appropriate for the overweight children. But remember, healthy eating and exercise habits are good for us all!

Share
Google Buzz
Email This Post Email This Post